PianoChords.studio

Helpless by Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young

Piano chords, voicings & structure breakdown · 17 steps · 4 unique chords

Intro (×2)Step 1 of 17

D

LeftD2, A2RightA3, D4, F♯4
C4D2A2A3D4F♯4
Left hand Right hand Middle C (C4)

No source cited for this step

Harmonic Analysis & Structure

Overview

Key: D major · Chords used: 4 · Sections: 19

Form: Intro → A Section → A Section ×3 → B Section → Interlude → B Section → Interlude → A Section ×2 → B Section → Vamp → B Section → Vamp → B Section → Vamp → B Section → Vamp

Where these chords come from: a chord chart of this song written by a musician and shared on the iReal Pro forums, archived in the iReal Pro forum charts archived in ChoCo (de Berardinis et al., 2023). It's one musician's reading of the song, not a transcription checked against the recording. This page shows that chart as-is: the analysis below is generated directly from it by code, not written by AI. Consecutive repeats of a chord are shown once, and the piano voicings are our playable arrangement of each chord symbol, not a note-for-note transcription.

Section by section

Intro

  • D – A – G7 (×2)
    I – V – IV7

A Section 1

  • D – A – Gadd9 (×2)
    I – V – IVadd9

A Section 2

Same chords as A Section 1.

A Section 3

Same chords as A Section 1.

A Section 4

Same chords as A Section 1.

B Section 1

  • D – A – G7 – D – A
    I – V – IV7 – I – V

Interlude 1

  • G7
    IV7

B Section 2

Same chords as B Section 1.

Interlude 2

  • G7
    IV7
  • D – A – Gadd9 (×2)
    I – V – IVadd9

A Section 5

Same chords as A Section 1.

A Section 6

Same chords as A Section 1.

B Section 3

Same chords as B Section 1.

Vamp 1

  • G7
    IV7

B Section 4

Same chords as B Section 1.

Vamp 2

Same chords as Vamp 1.

B Section 5

Same chords as B Section 1.

Vamp 3

Same chords as Vamp 1.

B Section 6

Same chords as B Section 1.

Vamp 4

Same chords as Vamp 1.

Chord vocabulary

ChordRoman numeralRoleHeard in
DIHome chord (tonic)Intro, A Section, B Section, Interlude
AVIn the keyIntro, A Section, B Section, Interlude
G7IV7Outside the key (chromatic)Intro, B Section, Interlude, Vamp
Gadd9IVadd9In the keyA Section, Interlude

Sources & accuracy

  • Chords: the iReal Pro forum charts archived in ChoCo (de Berardinis et al., 2023). Community chord chart “Helpless” (credited “Neil Young (Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young)”, style Folk Ballad) from the forum file linked here, CC BY 4.0 via ChoCo. Performer/songwriter confirmed from Wikidata.
  • Section names: from the chart's own markings: section names written on the chart (Intro, Verse, Chorus…) are kept, and rehearsal letters are shown as “A Section”, “B Section” and so on (the B of an AABA song is called the Bridge).
  • Cross-check: the iReal Pro forum charts archived in ChoCo (de Berardinis et al., 2023). Community chord chart “Helpless - Flinner” (credited “Young Neil”, style Pop Rock) from the forum file linked here, CC BY 4.0 via ChoCo. Performer/songwriter confirmed from Wikidata. A separately posted chart of the same song; its chords match this page's closely when both are read in the same key (similarity 100%).
  • Chord charts are often written in a key that suits a particular singer or band, so this may not be the key of the original recording.
  • About the song: Wikipedia.
  • Verified: two community charts of this song, posted in different forum threads, agree on its harmony. They're still charts, not transcriptions checked against the recording.
  • Rhythm and chord durations aren't shown; each step is one chord change.

Sources & Accuracy

Every chord on this page comes from the community chart listed first below. Piano voicings are our arrangement of the reported chord symbols, not a note-for-note transcription.

  • Chords from a chart a musician wrote and shared on the iReal Pro forums (archived in the ChoCo research dataset); may be in a different key from the recording, and not checked against it.

    Community chord chart “Helpless” (credited “Neil Young (Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young)”, style Folk Ballad) from the forum file linked here, CC BY 4.0 via ChoCo. Performer/songwriter confirmed from Wikidata.

  • Chords from a chart a musician wrote and shared on the iReal Pro forums (archived in the ChoCo research dataset); may be in a different key from the recording, and not checked against it.

    Community chord chart “Helpless - Flinner” (credited “Young Neil”, style Pop Rock) from the forum file linked here, CC BY 4.0 via ChoCo. Performer/songwriter confirmed from Wikidata. A separately posted chart of the same song; its chords match this page's closely when both are read in the same key (similarity 100%).

All Piano Voicings

#SectionChordLeft handRight handSources
1Intro (×2)DD2, A2A3, D4, F♯4—
2Intro (×2)AA2, E3A3, C♯4, E4—
3Intro (×2)G7G2, D3B3, D4, F4—
4A Section 1 (×2)DD2, A2A3, D4, F♯4—
5A Section 1 (×2)AA2, E3A3, C♯4, E4—
6A Section 1 (×2)Gadd9G2, D3A3, B3, D4—
7B Section 1DD2, A2F♯3, A3, D4—
8B Section 1AA2, E3A3, C♯4, E4—
9B Section 1G7G2, D3B3, D4, F4—
10B Section 1DD2, A2A3, D4, F♯4—
11B Section 1AA2, E3A3, C♯4, E4—
12Interlude 1G7G2, D3B3, D4, F4—
13Interlude 2, part 1G7G2, D3B3, D4, F4—
14Interlude 2, part 2 (×2)DD2, A2A3, D4, F♯4—
15Interlude 2, part 2 (×2)AA2, E3A3, C♯4, E4—
16Interlude 2, part 2 (×2)Gadd9G2, D3A3, B3, D4—
17Vamp 1G7G2, D3F3, B3, D4—